Used Cars for Sale


Although every reasonable effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained on this site, absolute accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This site, and all information and materials appearing on it, are presented to the user "as is" without warranty of any kind, either express or implied. All vehicles are subject to prior sale. Price does not include applicable tax, title, license, processing and/or $251.05 documentation fees, or certification fees, if applicable. ‡Vehicles shown at different locations are not currently in our inventory (Not in Stock) but can be made available to you at our location within a reasonable date from the time of your request, not to exceed one week. Tax, Title and Tags are not included in vehicle prices shown and must be paid by the purchaser. While great effort is made to ensure the accuracy of the information on this site, errors do occur so please verify information with a customer service rep. This is easily done by calling us at Sales 1-317-342-0583 or by visiting us at the dealership.
**With approved credit. Terms may vary. Monthly payments are estimates only.

Fuel economy ratings and driving range figures are based on EPA estimates for new vehicles, and actual mileage and range may vary depending on factors such as driving conditions, vehicle maintenance, fuel quality, driving habits, and modifications. For used vehicles, the EPA estimates were generated when the vehicle was new, and actual fuel economy may differ more significantly due to factors like age, maintenance history, and vehicle condition. Therefore, EPA estimates should be used as a general guide for comparison purposes only and not as a guarantee of actual fuel economy or driving range, especially when considering used vehicles.

Used Vehicles for Sale

Buying a used ride can be as exciting as purchasing a new one. That’s because we carry a great selection of quality used rides that can offer you as much value as new cars. Why pay full price when you can take the used vehicle route and still get a dream ride?

Andy Mohr Toyota wants to help you discover some capable used vehicles for sale near Avon, Indianapolis, and Plainfield, Indiana.

About Our Used Vehicles

When buying a vehicle, choosing a used one can offer significant benefits. Used cars typically have a lower price tag, and come with slower depreciation rates compared to new vehicles. This means you’ll get more value for your money and can drive off in a car that holds its worth.

Plus, with our diverse selection of used Toyota models, you can find a car that fits your lifestyle, whether commuting around town or taking a road trip. With a used Toyota, you can enjoy a high-quality vehicle at an affordable price, all while knowing you’ve made a wise investment.

Check out our used models, and you’ll see that many of them feel like new.

Certified Pre-Owned Toyota Vehicles for Sale

We take pride in stocking our lot with vehicles that are all in top shape, and this is especially true of our certified pre-owned models. Each Toyota-certified pre-owned ride is a later-model vehicle with low mileage. It has gone through our thorough 160-point inspection to ensure it’s running like new, and you’ll get a CARFAX® Vehicle History Report™ to confirm its condition and maintenance history.

Our certified pre-owned vehicles provide additional peace of mind, so explore the ins and outs of what we have for you to try out.

Schedule a Used Car Test Drive

Getting behind the wheel is one of the most important steps when buying a used vehicle. A test drive lets you feel how the car performs on the road, experience the comfort of the interior, and try out key features firsthand. A test drive will help you determine if the vehicle meets your needs. You can schedule a test drive directly through our website to make it even easier.

Simply select your favorite used Toyota or used model from our inventory, pick a time that works for you, and we'll have the car ready for you to test. Our team will be there to guide you through the experience and answer any questions.

Buying a Used Vehicle Online

We’ll be happy to see you walk through our doors so we can help you find your dream Toyota. You can also search from the comfort of your home or during your lunch break. You’ll be relieved by the ease of the process when you use our search filters to narrow down all the choices and find your next ride.

Begin with the Year, Body Style, or Mileage filters to pinpoint the model and condition you’re looking for. The Cylinder and Drivetrain filters will single out vehicles with the engine configurations you like. Then, you can use the Features filter to select the interior comforts and amenities you’d like.

Choose your favorite from the search results, and lean on our help to grab the keys.

Home Delivery for a Used Vehicle

Our at-home delivery option will make shopping for a used vehicle more convenient. Once you’ve found the perfect vehicle online, you can complete the entire purchase process without stepping foot in the dealership.

We offer delivery to your home or office, allowing you to receive your vehicle wherever it’s most convenient. Would you prefer to pick up the car in person? Just schedule a pickup time, and we’ll have the vehicle ready.

Our flexible delivery and pickup options allow you to enjoy a seamless car-buying experience from the comfort of your home.

Used Vehicle Special Offers

Looking for an even better deal on your next used Toyota? Be sure to check out our latest used vehicle specials. We regularly update our inventory with exclusive offers on select pre-owned models, making saving on your next purchase easier.

If you're searching for a fuel-efficient sedan or a spacious SUV, our specials can help you find a vehicle that fits your budget. Take advantage of these limited-time discounts and drive away with a quality used car for less. Visit our website or contact our dealership to learn more about the current offers.

How to Trade in Your Vehicle

Upgrading to your next vehicle is easy when you trade in your current car. Our streamlined trade-in process lets you quickly get an estimate for your vehicle’s value using our online Value Your Trade tool. Simply provide details about your car, including its make, model, and condition, and we’ll give you an instant estimate. Once you receive your offer, you can apply it directly toward purchasing a used car, lowering the overall cost.

Bring your trade-in to our dealership, and after a quick inspection, we’ll finalize the offer and help you transition smoothly into your new-to-you ride. Smoothly transition from your current ride to your used Toyota when you trade in with us.

Used Vehicle Financing Tools and Resources

After you zero in on the Toyota that checks all your boxes, head to our finance page. While seated on your favorite couch, you could get pre-approved for your vehicle loan.

Plan your purchase using our payment calculator tool. It will give you an idea of your monthly payments and financial information.

Complete our online finance application to get the process rolling now, and we’ll put together a repayment plan that works for you.

Test Drive Our Used Vehicles for Sale Today

Our friendly staff at Andy Mohr Toyota is waiting to show off our used cars for sale. You’ll find a favorite and enjoy great fun driving your next ride around Avon, Plainfield, or Indianapolis, IN. Contact us to test drive your favorite now!